DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville

4.0 ( 139 reviews )
Checking... 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM See Hours
$10–20
20 S State St #K, Westerville, OH 43081, United States
+1 614-463-0522

Located at 20 S State St #K in Westerville, OH, DiCarlo’s Pizza has quickly captured the tastebuds of locals and visitors alike with its unique Ohio Valley pizza style. Reviewers rave about the distinctive square-cut slices, featuring a crispy crust that perfectly holds a fresh, chunky tomato sauce with flavorful Ezzo's pepperoni. The addition of cold provolone cheese melted right before serving adds a delightful twist, making each bite a memorable experience.

Customer Kristine Provan noted a return to form under new ownership, highlighting the authentic taste reminiscent of original recipes. Chelsie Lakeman appreciated the savory quality of the pizza and the friendly service, which sets a welcoming tone for diners. The bustling atmosphere, as experienced by Bill Golden, speaks to its popularity, often selling out daily. With options to order slices or take-and-bake, DiCarlo’s presents a flexible dining experience that suits various preferences.

Overall, DiCarlo’s Pizza is not just a meal; it’s an experience that blends new ownership with beloved tradition. Whether you're a veteran of the Valley-style pizza or a newcomer, you’re sure to enjoy the hearty flavors and inviting ambiance.

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Outdoor seating
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
  • Highlights
    • Fast service
  • Popular for
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Offerings
    • Alcohol
    • Beer
    • Cocktails
    • Comfort food
    • Happy-hour drinks
    • Quick bite
    • Wine
  • Dining options
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Catering
    • Dessert
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
  • Crowd
    • Family friendly
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot

Reviews For DiCarlo’s Pizza - Westerville

Kristine Provan
Jul 2,2025
My husband and I are from the Valley. We KNOW DiCarlos. We were not surprised when the location closed a few months back because the recipe was not right. We just tried again under new owners and I'm pleased to say it's legit. Same great valley taste. Looking forward to coming back!
Chelsie Lakeman
Jun 15,2025
I had been hesitant to try DiCarlo's after hearing mixed reviews. However, I was next door getting my nails done and the nail artist said she enjoys their pizza. I decided to finally take someone's positive review and trust it. I am so glad I did - it is definitely a different sort of pizza but totally delicious in my opinion. The service was great and the price can't be beat. Hoping I can sway the rest of my family to try it too!
MRBARBQ 1
Jun 2,2025
Decided to try to go to the DiCarlo's Pizza in Westerville today. A lot of hype behind this coming to Westerville. Ordered the Pepperoni and cheese pizza, also a pepperoni roll. The pizza is cut into squares and has a crispy texture.The sauce had a great chunky tomato consistency to it, super fresh flavor to it. The cold provolone cheese on top blended well with the Ezzo's big pepperoni. The whole thing was a new experience. The Pepperoni roll had a great outside texture to it, the cheese and pepperoni blended well and was baked perfectly. I just have to mention the friendliest staff of the worker's here, everyone was willing to talk about their product. No doubt I will return.
Bill Golden
May 19,2025
Had my first DiCarlo's Ohio Valley Pizza (Westerville, OH) today. It's a different experience. Cheese and w/pepperoni are your options. Crust is pretty thin (which I like). Cheese goes on at the end so it will be cold to melted, depending on how long you wait to eat. Order slices in pairs - six slices fit one box. You can take and bake for the same price. We were there on a Wednesday at 4:45 pm and the place was packed. Amazing! I heard someone say that they sell out every single day, so it's pretty popular. Didn't realize there were so many Ohio Valley folks here in Westerville. Ha! :-)
My Next Home Columbus - Michael Dalton, REALTOR
Apr 30,2025
Lunch at DiCarlo's Pizza in Westerville today and my first experience with "Ohio Valley" style pizza. Did not disappoint. Ordered the Pepperoni and WOW! The pizza is cut into squares and has a crispy texture due to using baking pans. Great sauce with a super fresh flavor to it. The cold provolone cheese on top is a great touch!! I will be back!!
dswaugh
Apr 27,2025
If Brandon is working, I’m there. This dude can make pizza. I’m a transplant from the Steubenville, Ohio/Weirton, WV area, where I grew up on DiCarlo’s, and until now, my sons and I have had to drive over two hours to get our fix of Valley pizza. Well, now we don’t have to, cause there are two legit DiCarlo’s franchises right here in our own back yard. And both are very good. We especially like the Westerville location, though, because it’s closer for us, and Brandon is rock solid consistent in making his pies. If you’re from the Ohio Valley and crave a slice of original DiCarlo’s Pizza, this is the closest you’re going to get here in C-Bus. Great pizza. Great location. Great service. Hope it catches on.
Bluejackets Fan
Apr 7,2025
I grew up on Dicarlos Pizza. This style of pizza, in my opinion is by far the best. I've driven 25 miles out of my way before just to grab a few squares when I am back in the Ohio Valley area. Nothing else like it! I was very excited to visit the new Westerville location. Very easy to order, employees were friendly and the place was super clean. As much as this pains me to say, I was a little disappointed with my pizza. Dicarlos is known for their excellent crunchy crust, unfortunately half of my order, the crust was very thin and foldable. Will I be back? 110% yes because even an off day is better than any other pizza out there. Fingers crossed for vist #2. I will follow up with a second review after my next visit. UPDATE: As expected, 2nd visit was spot on! The crust was perfect! There is simply no better pizza out there. By the look of the lines today, the word is out just how good DiCarlos Pizza is. Give it a try. #yummy
Richie Phillips
Mar 25,2025
I just went back for the first time since they’ve been back open and I hope they make it. This seems like it should be right here very nice atmosphere. In this pizza I give it a 8 1/2

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Christopher’s Cafe
(979 review)
Christopher’s Cafe
  • 3725 S Straits Hwy, Indian River, MI 49749, United States
Cafe
+1 231-238-9312
Stacey's Country Kitchen
(306 review)
Stacey's Country Kitchen
  • 205 Spring Branch Rd, Dunn, NC 28334, United States
restaurant
+1 910-891-1880
Red Sake
(500 review)
Red Sake
  • 8410 Rea Rd Suite 100, Charlotte, NC 28277, United States
sushi restaurant
+1 980-498-1578
Pizza Pilgrims Covent Garden
(3736 review)
Pizza Pilgrims Covent Garden
  • 23 Garrick St, London WC2E 9BN, United Kingdom
Neapolitan restaurant
+44 20 7240 4145
Chapatas Street Nativitas
(139 review)
Chapatas Street Nativitas
  • C. Don Juan 91, Nativitas, Benito Juarez, 03500 Ciudad de Mexico, CDMX, Mexico
restaurant
Jilly's Cafe
(170 review)
Jilly's Cafe
  • 2614 Green Bay Rd, Evanston, IL 60201, United States
French restaurant
+1 847-869-7636
Darrell's Restaurant
(443 review)
Darrell's Restaurant
  • 1200 MacArthur Dr, Alexandria, LA 71303, United States
american restaurant
+1 318-625-7600
Pizza Donisi
(550 review)
Pizza Donisi
  • 1396 S 2nd St, Louisville, KY 40208, United States
Pizza restaurant
+1 502-213-0488
Banana Leaf Indian Restaurant - Downtown LA
(109 review)
Banana Leaf Indian Restaurant - Downtown LA
  • 701 W Cesar Estrada Chavez Ave #107, Los Angeles, CA 90012, United States
south indian restaurant
+1 213-372-5590
Siren Oyster Bar & Restaurant
(166 review)
Siren Oyster Bar & Restaurant
  • 687 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States
seafood restaurant
+1 347-689-4577